Why I decided to get a feeding tube for my mom dying of
end-stage Alzheimer’s disease.
My mom suffered Alzheimer’s disease; for ten years she was
symptomatic, but the last five were especially difficult. She started wandering
and would endeavor to leave the yard. One day, August 14, 2014, I came home
from work around midnight and she was missing. The cats were even frightened
knowing something was wrong. Panicking, I seen the telephone had a message and
the Emergency Room (ER) collected her.
She fell on the street about a block where I live, face down, on the
road. Her face was black and blue from the fall, but the ER scanned her entire
body without a single broken bone and no brain bleed. She was lucky a car did
not hit her. This changed my life forever. I could no longer work when I wanted
and was about to hand in my resignation having to watch over mom 24/7. My supervisor worked with me and he told me
to try working once a week, a four hour shift. That I did and my best friend
watched mom while I worked.
I put mom on hospice August 2018. Both VITAS and Cornerstone of Central Florida never did intravenous (IV) fluids to replenish dehydration because it became a
major struggle to get her to eat and drink adequately. From August 2018 to July 9, 2019 she went
from 150 pounds to 125 pounds. However, I managed to get her to eat and drink
with considerable difficulty.
July 8, 2019 I thought she had another urinary tract infection (UTI) and I took her to the ER. I feel it is a mistake to tell doctors your parent is under hospice and Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) because healthcare professionals then trivialize their care, thinking DNR means do not treat and just let them go. DNR only means no chest compressions, shocking and intubation. Mom tended to be dehydrated, and would retain urine; in addition, incontinence of bowel and bladder all predisposed to UTIs. Due to her insulin-dependent diabetes and metabolic syndrome, mom suffered stage three kidney disease for years. When I asked the Winter Haven Hospital Emergency Room doctor, Doran R. Heist, on July 9, 2019, how are mom's kidneys, for some reason he lied to me and said, “They are better than ever for years,” but he wanted her hospitalized. When asked why he said “she’s a ‘little’ dehydrated” and I said that is not unusual. I asked if he could give her a few bags of fluids and send her home due to end-stage Alzheimer’s which he agreed. On discharge from the ER, the discharge paper stated mom had "renal insufficiency," NOT complete kidney failure due to dehydration. Big difference.
July 8, 2019 I thought she had another urinary tract infection (UTI) and I took her to the ER. I feel it is a mistake to tell doctors your parent is under hospice and Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) because healthcare professionals then trivialize their care, thinking DNR means do not treat and just let them go. DNR only means no chest compressions, shocking and intubation. Mom tended to be dehydrated, and would retain urine; in addition, incontinence of bowel and bladder all predisposed to UTIs. Due to her insulin-dependent diabetes and metabolic syndrome, mom suffered stage three kidney disease for years. When I asked the Winter Haven Hospital Emergency Room doctor, Doran R. Heist, on July 9, 2019, how are mom's kidneys, for some reason he lied to me and said, “They are better than ever for years,” but he wanted her hospitalized. When asked why he said “she’s a ‘little’ dehydrated” and I said that is not unusual. I asked if he could give her a few bags of fluids and send her home due to end-stage Alzheimer’s which he agreed. On discharge from the ER, the discharge paper stated mom had "renal insufficiency," NOT complete kidney failure due to dehydration. Big difference.
As for evidence-based research, not much is published
regarding the opinion of doctors and nurses reflecting quality of care with DNR
patients. Working as a Registered Nurse I tend to find doctors and nurses think
DNR means do not treat, just let them die, and even seen this in real life.
When I told that ER doctor she was under hospice and a DNR, this lack of caring
shown through when he lied and told me her kidneys were “better than ever” when
they were failed. Betsy McCaughey of the
New York Post wrote DNR on your chart could cost you your life due to poorer
quality of care, thinking it means Dying, Not Recovering (2018). I agree with
this. Your chances of death are much
higher with a DNR, reflecting the quality of care (Bruckel, et al., 2018).
When I got home around midnight I checked her patient
portal; I am Power of Attorney (POA) and her kidneys reflected complete failure
due to dehydration. At that time I struggled to give her adequate fluids and
before I sent her to the ER a few days prior, Cornerstone hospice’s nurse
practitioner, Janice Heidel, belittled me saying, “you can give fluids through fruit,” while
refusing to allow a simple IV of fluids, and I thought that stupid bitch can
just go to hell. Sorry those were my
thoughts. She was unable to “suck on fruit” much less eat anything. Sucking on fruit, which mom could not do, is not enough to hydrate a bird. The ARNP bitch was
telling me her “body was shutting down and did not need it,” lying to me. No
her body was not shutting down due to a terminal illness—she just forgot HOW to
eat and drink. Her body was not shutting down as though she had cancer. Her
brain was just unable to process the information. Post feeding tube she assimilates large amounts of food and fluid just fine.
When I got mom home from the ER on July 8th, mom ate a half bag of popcorn, a lot of ice cream with protein shake. That surprised me. However, for the first time she was unable to ambulate to the bedroom; she normally uses a walker with total guidance myself holding her hands on the walking and she could walk. My best friend and I put her in the wheelchair and wheeled her back to bed, and it took maximum effort to lift her and literally throw her on the bed due to dead weight. That was the last time she ever walked.
July 9, 2019 mom fell in a coma and all day long I could not awaken her even while cleaning her. I figured she was dying and since she was not getting better I just wanted her to die a peaceful death. Ironically when she was in the ER, the IV infiltrated and over a half bag of fluid went into her arm tissues. They had considerable difficulty restarting a new one, but managed with a vein finder.
July 10, 2019 I check on mom around 5 am and got emotional holding her hand and crying which she squeezed me hand and woke up. At that time mom had her moments of clarity and I asked her if she wanted to go to the hospital. She nodded “yes,” trying to answer yes. Her arm was no longer swollen from the infiltrated IV; she had about a half bag of fluids stored in her arm which apparently her body was utilizing while she was in a coma; on July 10th, her arm was no longer swollen.
When I got mom home from the ER on July 8th, mom ate a half bag of popcorn, a lot of ice cream with protein shake. That surprised me. However, for the first time she was unable to ambulate to the bedroom; she normally uses a walker with total guidance myself holding her hands on the walking and she could walk. My best friend and I put her in the wheelchair and wheeled her back to bed, and it took maximum effort to lift her and literally throw her on the bed due to dead weight. That was the last time she ever walked.
July 9, 2019 mom fell in a coma and all day long I could not awaken her even while cleaning her. I figured she was dying and since she was not getting better I just wanted her to die a peaceful death. Ironically when she was in the ER, the IV infiltrated and over a half bag of fluid went into her arm tissues. They had considerable difficulty restarting a new one, but managed with a vein finder.
July 10, 2019 I check on mom around 5 am and got emotional holding her hand and crying which she squeezed me hand and woke up. At that time mom had her moments of clarity and I asked her if she wanted to go to the hospital. She nodded “yes,” trying to answer yes. Her arm was no longer swollen from the infiltrated IV; she had about a half bag of fluids stored in her arm which apparently her body was utilizing while she was in a coma; on July 10th, her arm was no longer swollen.
I asked mom again if she wanted to go to the ER. She nodded
yes. I called Cornerstone hospice, took her to the hospital, where they
rehydrated her and her kidneys rapidly restored back to baseline. She went from
complete kidney failure to baseline in a matter of days. I revoked her hospice
during that admission and decided to put a feeding tube in her for the
following reasons, other than her wanting help.
Evidence-based research overall says feeding tubes do not extend life for end-stage Alzheimer’s disease. None of them recommend it. What they are not telling you is that death by dehydration is a very slow, horrible process, and you as the caregiver must watch this lingering inhumane process. It can take up to two, even three weeks, to die of dehydration (Malpas, 2017). A friend of mine described her grandmother in a nursing home also forgot how to eat and drink, and after a lengthy family discussion they got a feeding tube put in because it would be monstrous to watch someone you truly love slowly die in that hideous manner. I concurred with this. Although mom had end-stage Alzheimer’s and now got to the point she no longer communicates to me, she will not die of dehydration. Her kidneys will not starve of fluids, and the administration of medications possible.
While it is cruel to give fluids and tube feeding to someone
who is actively dying such as end-stages of cancer, this is not the case with
Alzheimer’s disease. All one needs to do is check for residuals to see if the
fluids are being assimilated. Simple nursing care.
The surgery was not as complicated as I originally believed;
mom’s percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) tube only
took about 10 minutes. Although complications may occur with any kind of
surgery, the chances of this happening are minimal. “A total of 563 PEGs were identified. The 30-day mortality
rate was 7.8% (44/563), and the 7-day early accidental dislodgement rate was
4.1% (23/563). The total lifetime accidental PEG dislodgement rate was 12.8%
(72/563). Of the 72 dislodged PEGs, 49 occurred after discharge from rehabilitation
or nursing facilities” (Rosenberger, Newhook, Schirmer, & Sawyer, 2011).
Also, “Minor complications range from 13%
to 40%, and major complications vary from 0.4% to 4.4%” (Sealock & Munot, 2018).
This seems to indicate most dislodgements occur during patient transfers and
care such as cleaning and bathing, while not securing the tube with some kind
of binder. For mom, I used a tube top I
found on Amazon; the typical abdominal binder is very heavy, confining and
uncomfortable.
Considering she would have
died slowly of dehydration which is 100% fatal, I had no choice but to take a
chance with the PEG tube. I was able to
reinstate her hospice upon discharge since the PEG tube was considered
pre-existing. Hospice also said if the tube is accidently dislodged they will
allow ER visits to get it put back in; otherwise I would have avoided hospice
and to with regular Medicare and home health.
Postop the second week, she
has never attempted to pull out her feeding tube as it is concealed with the
tube top. I keep a close eye on the insertion site.
Advanced Directive Thoughts
When a person signs an
Advanced Directive, say, ten years ago, when they were healthier and death was
not imminent, it is easy for people to sign “do nothing” when it comes to
feeding tubes, and other life-sustaining measures. However, when death is
staring them in their face, perceptions may change. While I was once able to walk my mom in the
park daily for a quarter of a mile, there were many times she did not want to.
I asked her if she wanted to die. She said or nodded “no” and would get up and
do her daily exercise with her walker. I
believe this kept her going for a few more years, and they were quality
years. Even while mom suffered very
end-stages of Alzheimer’s she has her moments of clarity. When I asked her
twice if she wanted to go to the hospital, both times she nodded yes and tried
to speak yes. When the ambulance came and collected her on the stretcher, they
asked if she was comfortable, and she said yes. Clearly at that moment she
wanted help, even though her Advanced Directive said otherwise. In other words,
this advanced directive – like your own opinions – are not necessarily the “be
all” – it is only if you have nothing else to go on. Mom clearly wanted help.
Conclusion
Advanced Directives are not
written in stone; a person’s opinion may change with the passage of time and
when death is actually staring at them in the face. Aside from mom acknowledged
she wanted treatment, although mom has end-stage Alzheimer’s, she has her
moments of clarity. Supposing mom totally lost the ability to walk and talk, and
every piece of evidence based research advises against a PEG tube, I could not
bear to watch my mom die slowly of dehydration—a process that may take weeks. I
do not regret taking a chance on the PEG tube. You
have to truly be a monster to watch someone you truly love to take that long to
die, and be okay with that, when a PEG tube is available. Even with risks of
surgery, I would have much rather her die quicker in the hospital than very
slowly from dehydration at home, so I took that risk. Health care professionals including nurse practitioners should never lie to the family and feed misinformation, and tell the truth: People even with end-stage Alzheimer's bodies are not shutting down--they merely forgot how to swallow food and water, and by withholding fluids you allow them to die slowly of dehydration, which is a very slow, horrible death. DNR does not mean "let them die," but no chest compressions, shocking and intubation. Treat otherwise such as fluids and antibiotics in accordance to family and patient wishes.
References
Bruckel, J., Nallamothu, B.,
Ling, F., Howell, E., Lowenstein, C., Thomas, S., ... & Walkey, A. (2018).
DO-NOT-RESUSCITATE STATUS AND RISK-STANDARDIZED MORTALITY FOR ACUTE MYOCARDIAL
INFARCTION: IMPLICATIONS FOR PUBLIC REPORTING AND REIMBURSEMENT. Journal of the American
College of Cardiology, 71(11 Supplement),
A25. doi: 10.1016/S0735-1097(18)30566-7
Malpas, P. J.
(2017). Dying is much more difficult than you’d think: A death by dehydration. The Permanente journal, 21. doi: 10.7812/TPP/16-148
McCaughey, B.
(2018, March 27). Beware: Hospitals think ‘do not resuscitate’ means you
don’t want to live. Retrieved from NY Post:
https://nypost.com/2018/03/27/beware-hospitals-think-do-not-resuscitate-means-you-dont-want-to-live/.
Rosenberger, L.
H., Newhook, T., Schirmer, B., & Sawyer, R. G. (2011). Late accidental
dislodgement of a percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy tube: an underestimated
burden on patients and the health care system. Surgical endoscopy, 25(10), 3307-3311.
Retrieved from https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00464-011-1709-y
Sealock, R. J.,
& Munot, K. (2018). Common gastrostomy feeding tube complications and
troubleshooting. Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 16(12), 1864-1869.
doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cgh.2018.07.037